Echo Hotel Aviation Law Briefings

This weekly briefing series outlines recent decisions and news that affect the aviation sector.

The articles listed below are intended to provide readers with general information. They should not be regarded or relied upon as legal advice or opinion.

Filter By:

February 7, 2017 – Class Actions Certified Against Air Canada

February 7, 2017

DECISIONS Class Action Certification – Fuel surcharge – Choquette c. Air Canada, 2017 QCCS 234 Claim that fuel surcharge disproportionate compared to actual fuel cost – Defendant disputed jurisdiction of Court – Court found it has jurisdiction – Claim respects all four criteria of class action – Class action certified   CANADIAN TRANSPORTATION AGENCY DECISIONS Application – ACM Air Charter Luftfahrtgesellschaft mbH – Order No. 2017-A-11 Exemptions from the application of paragraphs 33.1(b) and 73(2)(c) and section 33.2 of the Air Transportation Regulations, SOR/88-58, as amended Application – Delta Air Lines, Inc. carrying on business as Delta Air Lines, as…

Read More +

January 31, 2017 – Pilot and AME Jointly Liable

January 31, 2017

DECISIONS Appeal – Freedom of expression – Cooperstock c. United Airlines Inc., 2017 QCCA 44 Appellant seeking provisional stay of injunction under appeal – Freedom of expression not infringed – Dismissed with costs Decision under appeal: United Airlines inc. c. Cooperstock, 2016 QCCS 4645 Judgement – Liability – British Columbia (Workers’ Compensation Board) v. Flanagan Enterprises (Nevada) Inc., 2017 BCSC 99 Case arising from plane crash due to engine failure – US and Canadian jurisdictions – Regulatory framework – Whether Transport Canada owes duty of care to plaintiff – Responsibility for plane maintenance program – Maintenance inspector found liable –…

Read More +

January 24, 2017 – Westjet Flight Attendant Union Drive May be Suspended

January 24, 2017

DECISIONS Adjournment Application – Claim due to passenger injury – Hayer v. Qatar Airways, 2016 BCSC 2477 Defendants seeking trial adjournment – Witness unavailable for trial – Injuries of passenger not properly settled for trial – Dismissed, trial to proceed as scheduled Application – Independent medical examination – Yu et al v 171817 Canada Inc., 2016 NWTSC 73 Defendant seeking IME in British Columbia – Plaintiff wants IME in California or by videoconference – Allowed, Plaintiff to attend IME in Vancouver in conjunction with examination for discovery Human Rights – Dismissal – McKenna v. Capitol Taxi – Ottawa, 2017 HRTO…

Read More +

January 17, 2017 – Fitness to Fly

January 17, 2017

DECISIONS Passenger Claim – Unfit to fly – Viens c. Sunwing, 2016 QCCQ 15820 $15,000 claim due to refusal to allow passenger to fly without medical certificate – Passenger obtained certificate but flight had departed – Decision to prohibit passenger to fly was made using all reasonable tools and with safety of all passengers in mind – Dismissed Discipline and termination – Unjust dismissal – Molina et Grand Falls Aviation Service Ltd., Re, 2016 CarswellNat 7018 Employee was dismissed – Employee brought unjust dismissal complaint under Canada Labour Code – Employee worked for period of six months in 2013 and…

Read More +

January 10, 2017 – Drugs, Alcohol and Pilots

January 10, 2017

DECISIONS Judicial Review – Termination payments – Raymond c. Bernier, 2016 CF 1403 Review of decision that successor employer was responsible for termination pay – Decision was reasonable – Employment terms amended between bankrupt and successor employer – Not continuous employment – Dismissed, payment order upheld Appeal – Failure to grant security clearance – Agosti v. Canada (Transport), 2016 FC 1410 Procedural fairness – Exception for late affidavit – Decision was reasonable – Jurisprudence provided Minister could “err on the side of caution” – Dismissed with costs Grievance – Termination for theft – Air Canada v Unifor Local 2002, 2016…

Read More +

January 3, 2017 – Pilot demotion not constructive dismissal

January 3, 2017

DECISIONS Motion – Security – Kelowna Flightcraft Air Charter Ltd. v Kales Group BV, 2016 ONSC 8015 Airfreight services provided – Notice to terminate contract and withhold payment – No right to specific fund – Matter is simple Claim/Counterclaim without need for security – Dismissed Employment – Wrongful Dismissal – Parker and Trans North Turbo Air Ltd., Re, 2016 CarswellNat 6708 Helicopter instructor/ pilot – Removed from Base Manager role due to request for leave – Pilot acquiesced to new position – Employee not constructively dismissed Appeal – Workplace Injury – Decision No. 2018/16, 2016 CarswellOnt 20205 Airline customer service…

Read More +

December 27, 2016 – Drone operators: Stay off TC’s naughty list

December 27, 2016

DECISIONS Arbitration – Interpretation – Jazz Aviation LP v Canadian Flight Attendant Union (CFAU), 2016 CanLII 87715 Collective Agreement – Clause interpretation – Flight attendant subject to reassignment Appeal – Indirect air service providers – Lukács v. Canada (Transportation Agency), 2016 FCA 314 Resellers – CTA determined not operating “air service” – CTA decision was reasonable and within its jurisdiction – Dismissed   CANADIAN TRANSPORTATION AGENCY DECISIONS Application – Shoreline Aviation, Inc. – Decision No. 372-A-2016 Pursuant to subsection 73(2) of the Canada Transportation Act, S.C., 1996, c.10, as amende Application – Air Canada also c.o.b. as Air Canada rouge…

Read More +

December 20, 2016 – Pilot Pathway Programs Continue to Grow

December 20, 2016

DECISIONS Supreme Court of Canada – Application for Leave to Appeal – Delta Air Lines Inc. v. Lukács, 2016 CarswellNat 6502 Lower Court decision: Lukács v. Canadian Transportation Agency, 2016 FCA 220   CANADIAN TRANSPORTATION AGENCY DECISIONS Application – Partner Jet Inc. – Order No. 2016-A-212 Exemptions from the application of paragraphs 33.1(b) and 73(2)(c) and sections 33.2 and 103.3 of the Air Transportation Regulations, SOR/88-58, as amended Application – WestJet – Order No. 2016-A-215 Exemption from the application of section 59 of the Canada Transportation Act, S.C., 1996, c. 10, as amended Suspension – Sky Wings Aviation Academy Ltd. – Order…

Read More +

December 13, 2016 – Westjet pilots attempting to unionize – again.

December 13, 2016

DECISIONS Appeal – Workplace injury recurrence – Hébert et Innotech Aviation ltée, 2016 QCTAT 6658 Employee claimed workplace injury reoccurred – Employer and Commission deny recurrence and ordered repayment by Employee to Employer – Employee appealed Commission decision – Allowed – Reoccurrence of workplace injury found – No repayment required for period Employee was absent due to recurrence of workplace injury Passenger claim – Reimbursement for missed connection – Drapeau c. Air Canada, 2016 QCCQ 12923 Passenger claimed missed connection was responsibility of airline – Missed connection caused by delay in Customs – Airline not responsible for extraordinary delays by…

Read More +

December 6, 2016 – Employer Wins Training Bond Case

December 6, 2016

DECISIONS Constructive Dismissal – Training Bond – Wildcat Helicopters Inc. v. Ellis, 2016 BCSC 2214 Employer claim for reimbursement of training bond as per employment agreement – Employee failed to prove constructive dismissal – Employer awarded full training bond Judicial Review – Security Clearance – Britz v Canada (Attorney General), 2016 FC 1286 Flight Attendant denied security clearance renewal – Association with Hells Angels – Decision unreasonable – Judicial Review granted – Redetermination ordered Application – Jurisdiction – Jaffary v. ASP Incorporated, 2016 HRTO 1528 Allegation of discrimination by ASP – Duty of ASP security officers at GTAA – Work…

Read More +